Write "Despair" Without Using the Word
Show and tell are two narrative choices, each with its own narrative purpose. Showing a scene slows the pace, placing the reader inside a character's thoughts. This option is useful when a moment needs time for the emotions to sink in. Telling a scene quickens the pace, acknowledging that something happened while keeping the focus on what comes next. When deciding on pacing, consider how much you want the reader to live inside it.
One thing I wanted to do in my biography is let the reader understand the despair that Arlinda felt, leading up to her big medical reveal. Here is the scene:
The doctors continued their search using more comprehensive tests and treatments without the financial restraint of self-pay. In getting health insurance, Arlinda experienced a feeling she had long forgotten—relief. It was the exhale after holding her breath for too long.
She held onto this gift as a promise to herself to keep moving. Keep breathing. Keep believing that this ordeal will one day be behind her.
To celebrate the good news, Arlinda peeled back the lid on a can of chicken noodle soup. The crunching of the can opener chuckled at her in discouragement. Despite the can’s protest, she poured the pale broth into a saucepan, watching it simmer into something almost resembling care.
She leaned over the pot as the soup warmed on the stovetop. The scent thin. Nothing like Madiere’s, who stirred love into every meal, adding onion, celery, and rosemary. Madiere could chase a fever away. Boil it down. Season it right. Serve it hotter than hot. Arlinda stirred with slow, wooden strokes, anticipating the salty broth on her tongue.
When it was ready, she carried the bowl to the kitchen table and lowered herself into the chair. Steam rose in soothing spirals, just like when she was a teenager. Here goes. She lifted a spoonful to her lips and blew wishes of comfort across it. Her will tried to overcome the twinge her throat would make. Still, she slurped gingerly from the first spoonful because, although tired and ragged, she still wanted to live. The rest went into the garbage disposal.
Despair is not just melodramatic sadness. I see it as a yearning, a pursuit of elusive hope, and the point before giving up.
In this scene, the soup represents Arlinda's despair. She has memories of herself as a child when her mother, Madiere, would nurse her back to health. Arlinda tries to soothe herself, but lacks the energy to do so in the way she is accustomed. I have tasted Arlinda's home-cooked food, and it was all delightful and properly seasoned. This time, she is going through the motions with wooden strokes, which also calls up in my mind the wooden spoon she used to stir a pot. The can of soup does not measure up to her expectations, yet she heats it up anyway. She knows that eating the soup will be painful, yet she tries anyway. And finally, the pain is too much, so she throws it all away.
Had this scene told us, "Arlinda was in despair," the reader may have accepted the label without feeling its weight. Because I show her reaching for comfort and coming up short, the reader experiences the same cycle she does. The choice to show allows the scene to express her sense of yearning and loss that defines despair in this biography.